A Review of “The Mysterious Epigenome: What Lies Beyond DNA”

*Posted by David Henderson, MD

As a Christian and a psychiatrist, I am always interested in the interplay between “nature and nurture” and how much of each influences our thoughts, our emotions and our behaviors. The Mysterious Epigenome: What Lies Beyond DNA demonstrates that the answer is not as simple as we might imagine. “It’s in our genes” has been the rallying cry of many scientists who would like to debunk the idea that faith and the power of the Holy Spirit can transform lives, even biologically. Yet the overriding ability of the epigenome to control the expression of DNA gives us another glimpse into the interaction between mind and body, encouraging those of us struggling against seemingly insurmountable forces of nature, can have an influence on our biology. Whether we struggle with drugs or alcohol, food or sexual addictions, even physical limitations, we can overcome our genetics and positively change our own future and that of the next generation.

Woodward and Gills attempt to provide evidence for two very important facts: 1. the genetic code and the process that controls its expression are so complex that they scream out, “Intelligent Design!” and 2. We are not just the product of natural selection, uncontrollable biological impulses, or psychic determinism. In arguing these two points, the authors spend approximately the first half of the book describing the various parts that make up the genome and epigenome. Then they provide several chapters on how our epigenome influences our physical and spiritual wellbeing.

Overall, the book is well written. However, I believe that the target audience who would most benefit from the read are those having a particular interest in cellular and molecular biology and want to speak apologetically on the subject matter with their non-Christian scientific friends. I found a lot of the descriptive illustrations to be a bit tedious and verbose. I think if the authors had been more succinct, the book would have been easier read. Much of the information presented, I had studied in medical school, so that helped, but I can imagine that a “layperson” would struggle to understand all the parallels between the cellular structure and computer networking, engineering, and movie trivia. (“Men In Black”?!)

As a clinician, I found the second half of the book more appealing. In chapter 9 , the authors answer the “so what” question. What impact does the epigenome have on our observable existence? They explain why women who eat larger amounts of B12 and folate in their diet can prevent fetal abnormalities during their child’s development. They reiterate the importance of avoiding smoking, maintaining a healthy diet and physical exercise. Interestingly enough, they also report that “a positive mental attitude can contribute to epigenetic health.” It has long been known in psychiatry that ongoing depression and high levels of stress increase cortisol levels, which decrease the body’s ability to respond to infection. The authors allude to the power of nurturing, a key component in modern day psychotherapy techniques, to produce well-adjusted adults who then provide that same nurturing to their children. Finally, the authors address the power of faith on the body and mind. Using an example of a study performed on prison inmates who “completed a spiritual formation program instituted by Prison Fellowship” and showed lower recidivism rates, the authors suggest that spiritual practices can have an influence on behavior which in turn alters genetic expression. Though it is a stretch to make a connection between behavioral changes and the genetic code, the evidence for behavioral changes alone is undeniable and evidence that the Holy Spirit can transform lives.

In conclusion, The Mysterious Epigenome is a valuable resource for those interested in delving into the intricate complexity, depth and beauty of God’s creation. Though we are called to have faith like a child, sometimes it helps to know just how far we are from fully comprehending the awesomeness of our God.

David L. Henderson, M.D. is a board-certified psychiatrist, author and speaker and the Department Chair of Psychology and Counseling at Criswell College. He also serves as an advisor to the board of directors of ROCK International, a non-profit organization seeking to be the lap of Jesus for impoverished children around the globe. He lives in Dallas with his wife, Angela and his three children. To find out more information about Dr. Henderson, his practice, ministry, and writing, visit purposebeyondpain.com.

This entry was posted in Review, Science and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to A Review of “The Mysterious Epigenome: What Lies Beyond DNA”

  1. jrigler says:

    Amazon categorizes this book under ‘Christian Books & Bibles > Theology’ and it is written by the directory of the C. S. Lewis Society. As a non-Christian, this certainly seems like a Christian book about science. It may indeed teach me quite a bit that I don’t know about cells, flagella, and similar systems. The idea of me reading this, however, would be congruous to one of you guys reading ‘The God Delusion’ since it also contains a good bit of scientific discussion about the specifics of biology and evolution. It would be a mistake to say that either book did not have an agenda. I would suggest that ‘The Epigenome: Molecular Hide and Seek’ is probably a unbiased treatment on the subject that would provide the non-scientist with the best understanding of the epigenome without the distraction of proving or disproving the existence or workings of God (filed under ‘Nature > Animals > Mammals’ rather than ‘Theology’):

    http://books.google.com/books/about/The_Epigenome.html?id=4hFou2DCzgEC

  2. Why would we want to read something unbiased? What’s wrong with being biased. The myth that scientific research is unbiased has been debunked by both Christians and Nonchristians a long time ago! Our metaphysics cannot help but influence the way we interpret results. Sorry, but that’s just a fact! A biased one, of course :)

  3. jrigler says:

    You would have to ask yourself why you are reading what you are reading. Would it make more sense to read this book as a way to primarily understand the epigenome or in order to add the epigenome to your apologetics toolkit? I was already an atheist when I read ‘The God Delusion’ and so it didn’t really convert my thinking but gave me a nice feeling that things that I had thought as a child were not unique. When I read ‘Godel, Escher, and Bach’ or ‘On LISP’, I was simply letting wonderful new ideas captivate me on their own merits with no real though of God or godlessness. This is the value of reading something unbiases by religion. Did these books have agendas? Absolutely. I am sure that the epigenome book that I suggested also has an agenda; to get more people thinking about what excited its writer. Scientists can be biases, but to borrow from Christianity, good scientist should see bias as a sinful aspect of their nature (or ego or human frailty) which they should try to fight against in their thinking and writing. Also, statements and arguments should stand on their own, regardless of the source. Imaging that the book that is recommended at the top of this post were written by a non-Christian. If it said exactly what it says now, it shouldn’t matter what the writers belief were because the text should stand on its own. When Darwin visited the Galapagos, did he have an agenda? I believe that he was simply interested in turtles and where the science would lead him. He may have been quite happy with what he found, or quite sad, but his primary duty was as reporter of what he observed so that others could repeat and confirm or deny his observations.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s